leighdb: (0)
leighdb ([personal profile] leighdb) wrote in [personal profile] kate_nepveu 2013-05-06 03:43 am (UTC)

Re: the Mandarin being a fake thing: Okay, so (a) I very assiduously avoided spoilers before seeing the movie, as usual, and (b) I am only familiar with most of Marvel comics canon via osmosis, so I went into this movie having pretty much *no idea* who the Mandarin was except the vague awareness that he was a villain who existed.

So when we first see Ben Kingsley coming in to what was (to me) extremely obviously a film set, and Guy Pearce standing around looking all smug while everyone else was freaking out, I swear that the first thing I thought was, "Oh, I bet he's totally just an actor and Guy Pearce is really the Mandarin." And then I turned out to be right and I was like, "Ha, called it!"

And it wasn't until I started looking at the IM3 stuff on the Internet afterwards that I even realized that this was, like, a BIG DEAL, that the Mandarin wasn't the Mandarin. Because as far as I was concerned, this had totally been set up earlier in the movie when Tony comments on how the Mandarin's accent was all wrong and so forth. I guess it's just interesting, because I didn't have the preconceived notion that the Mandarin was really real and so I didn't ignore the foreshadowing the movie provided.

I was also incredibly *relieved* to find out I was right, because up to that point I was starting to get seriously uncomfortable with the implied endorsement of American racism/xenophobia the Mandarin's shtick seemed to be supporting. To find out it was a deliberate play on (and actually an explicit *indictment* of) that xenophobia, both by Guy Pearce's character and by the movie itself, was both brilliant and faith-restoring. So well done, IM3. Way to have your comics canon cake and yet not repeat the previous chefs' mistakes in serving it.

Post a comment in response:

If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting

If you are unable to use this captcha for any reason, please contact us by email at support@dreamwidth.org