kate_nepveu: sleeping cat carved in brown wood (Default)

I've had this vague thesis for a while, that there two kinds of people, those who—well. Have a poll:

Open to: Registered Users, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 86

Tony Stark or Steve Rogers? (Marvel)

View Answers

42 (54.5%)

35 (45.5%)

Neal Caffrey or Peter Burke? (White Collar)

View Answers

23 (50.0%)

23 (50.0%)

Sherlock Holmes or John Watson? (Sherlock (BBC).)

View Answers

15 (21.4%)

55 (78.6%)


View Answers

28 (36.4%)

Ticky rejects the forced binary.
67 (87.0%)

(At one point I had more examples, but lost them. I also firmly expect to be in the minority on all of these, though I'm less certain whether there will be a pattern.)

kate_nepveu: sleeping cat carved in brown wood (Default)

Haywire: the weekend of Martin Luther King Jr. Day, I & the kids were staying with Chad's parents, and I escaped for a couple of hours to watch a movie. I was going to see Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy, but then I saw [livejournal.com profile] glvalentine's review of Haywire and decided to see it instead: partly because it was shorter and partly because it sounded really interesting.

I liked this less than Genevieve, for two reasons. One, I missed the first few minutes and spent most of the movie wondering if it provided some kind of context for the main character's goals and situation. I'm not sure why I felt vaguely aswim—maybe just sleep deprivation?—since in the end it was pretty simple: she was betrayed, she escaped, she finds out why, she makes them pay. I think I wasn't sure what she knew at any given time. (It is a Soderbergh movie, which means non-linear and lots of significant verbal omissions. One of which convinced me that a certain character was doing completely the opposite of what it turned out to be, which didn't help matters.) Two, I'm not that fond of the type of action movie this is. I love competence porn in capers or action movies, but I like either character development or a reveal to go with it (Ronin, The Bourne Identity, Ocean's Eleven). Haywire is instead in the "main character gets revenge and returns to status quo" mold, which I find unsatisfying. I didn't get a strong hook as the movie unfolded (character development), and I didn't have any reason to revisit my conclusions at the end (reveal). Instead I felt, as the credits came up, "That was it?", and was left with more abstract admiration than enjoyment.

So, if you like that kind of thing, you need to see this, and if you don't, it's worth background watching when it comes on basic cable in a few years.

The other two episodes in season two of Sherlock: "The Hounds of Baskerville" was very silly and not at all scary and entertained me in a way that almost entirely failed to engage my brain. Thus, I have nothing else to say about it.

"The Reichenbach Fall" was mostly terrific: I liked the updating of the conflict, and that Moriarty toned the swoopy down, and spoilers, minor and major )

Face Off: this is, of all things, an original reality show on the SyFy network, in which contestants design and execute special effects makeup. I saw some commercials for it and then found the whole season free on demand on my cable system one day when I was out of DVRed things to half-watch while dealing with the Pip. Anyway, I like seeing the different designs and all the craft involved, and generally find the judging clear, educational, and reasonable. Despite my best efforts, though, I find myself having opinions about the contestants as people, which I was trying to avoid because I know how manipulatively these shows can be cut to create interpersonal conflict. There's very little of that, however, so if you like how-to kinds of shows this is worth checking out.

White Collar: I dropped this show for a long time but the second half of this just-concluded season has also been maternity-leave TV fodder. Most of it was background noise, and I actually watched a couple episodes mostly on FF, but I thought the season finale was genuinely strong. (Well, except for the worst green-screening I have seen in quite some time.) And wow, Beau Bridges has a talent for playing characters who get on my last nerve (I watched SGA before SG-1 and so was introduced to General Landry in a much more confrontational posture).

kate_nepveu: sleeping cat carved in brown wood (Default)

You know, I was really dubious when I heard that Sherlock was going to be doing "A Scandal in Bohemia," because goodness knows its handling of women in the first season was pretty poor. But I watched the first bit and somehow got my hopes up in the case-montage sequence, because that was fun, so watched the rest yesterday as a pick-me-up.

Which was a mistake.

spoilers )

So is the rest of the season any better?

kate_nepveu: sleeping cat carved in brown wood (Default)

Last night, Chad and I watched the third and last episode of the BBC's Sherlock, "The Great Game," in its slightly-shortened-for-PBS version. (I skimmed the shooting script for the middle episode and decided that yes, it was eminently skippable.)

Non-spoilers: I liked it a little less than the first episode, I think because its over-the-top elements felt more gratuitous and aren't-I-clever. (One of these days I really will make an icon of Peter Falk saying "Yes, you're very smart, now shut up" from The Princess Bride.) And I disapprove on principle of season-ending cliffhangers. But I still enjoyed it well enough to look forward to the next season.

spoilers )

Additionally: "Paper Chase" and "Rematch" by [personal profile] sam_storyteller, a crossover series with White Collar in which Sherlock and Neal match skills. Gen, canon-typical violence; spoilers for White Collar through season one, as far as I can tell, and through "The Great Game" for Sherlock.

kate_nepveu: sleeping cat carved in brown wood (Default)

Thanks to [personal profile] sparkymonster's enthusiasm, finally got around to watching the first episode of this modern-day version of Sherlock Holmes off the DVR.

Non-spoilers: the plot kind of falls down at the end, but still, fun: I enjoyed the characters a lot (the guy playing Watson is going to be a terrific Bilbo, and, minorly, I liked that Lestrade was not bumbling), and the sense of humor it had, especially about its relationship to canon, and that it managed the atmosphere well enough that even the kind-of-silly climax was absorbing. I was not impressed with its treatment of disability, however.

spoilers )

I am told that the second episode is dreadful; I may just listen, but if I can't stand it, will I miss anything critical to the larger plot that I can't infer from the third?

October 2017

1234 56 7
8910 1112 1314
15 1617 18192021

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags