kate_nepveu | Harry Potter & the Chamber of Secrets (spoilers)

You're viewing

kate_nepveu's journal
Create a Dreamwidth Account Learn More

Reload page in style: site light

Proposition: the reason that Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is less interesting than the first book is that the story is mostly about someone other than Harry.

Discuss.

(Alternatively, what the heck was Bloomsbury UK thinking with the kids-version cover art for the seventh book? (See also: US version.))

ETA: I've booklogged this book & its predecessor.

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

From:

kate_nepveu

But could she have been, is I guess what I was thinking? The real plot happened largely out of sight of Harry, and just gets recounted by Tom; if it had been foregrounded, could it have been compelling? I don't see any reason why not.

I am looking forward to seeing how the third book holds up on audio. At this point I remember the movie a lot better.

From:

charlie-ego.livejournal.com

Oh, I see. I guess my answer to that would be that I don't think it *would* have been compelling, because Ginny at this point just doesn't have the... personality to bring it off. But yeah, I see what you mean in that if it *had* been focused on Harry (as is, say, the 4th book) it would have been more interesting to me.

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

Profile

Kate

Outside of a Dog

January 2025

S	M	T	W	T	F	S
			1	2	3	4
5	6	7	8	9	10	11
12	13	14	15	16	17	18
19	20	21	22	23	24	25
26	27	28	29	30	31

Tags

[time] in review [183]
anime [6]
- cowboy bebop [9]
- fullmetal alchemist (2003) [35]
- fullmetal alchemist brotherhood [31]
- martian successor nadesico [7]
- princess tutu [9]
- pumpkin scissors [2]
- samurai champloo [6]
- trigun [11]
- vision of escaflowne [6]
baseball [1]
being carded [4]
bittercon [7]
books [156]
- 100 first lines [3]
- booklog-in-exile [6]
- dark tower series [9]
- freedom and necessity daily [53]
- harry potter [11]
- jonathan strange & mr norrell [5]
- lord of the rings [55]
- moby dick [2]
- tale of genji [21]
- temeraire-verse [6]
- vorkosigan [3]
bullet journaling [1]
cars [11]
chad's books [11]
cheerful things [7]
clothes [2]
college hoops [6]
comics [5]
computers [2]
con or bust [30]
concussion [1]
cons [3]
- arisia
  - 2011 [1]
  - 2013 [1]
  - 2015 [4]
  - 2016 [6]
  - 2017 [3]
  - 2018 [4]
  - 2019 [3]
  - 2020 [3]
  - 2023 [3]
  - 2024 [5]
  - 2025 [1]
- boskone
  - 2003 [2]
  - 2004 [2]
  - 2005 [3]
  - 2006 [3]
  - 2007 [7]
  - 2008 [5]
  - 2009 [3]
  - 2010 [1]
  - 2011 [2]
- lunacon
  - 2013 [1]
- pippi to ripley
  - 2015 [2]
- readercon
  - 2003 [1]
  - 2005 [3]
  - 2006 [6]
  - 2007 [9]
  - 2009 [7]
  - 2010 [3]
  - 2011 [1]
  - 2014 [5]
  - 2015 [4]
  - 2016 [1]
  - 2017 [7]
  - 2018 [3]
  - 2019 [3]
  - 2023 [4]
  - 2024 [15]
- wiscon [1]
  - 2011 [8]
  - 2013 [2]
  - 2018 [2]
- world fantasy con
  - 2007 [11]
- worldcon
  - 2004 (noreascon) [9]
  - 2007 (nippon 2007) [13]
  - 2009 (anticipation) [21]
  - 2014 (loncon 3) [15]
cranky [17]
daily life [19]
dance [1]
daydreaming [1]
disability [1]
dogs [73]
donghua
- heaven official's blessing [1]
donorschoose [2]
dreams [4]
dreamwidth [13]
family [7]
fandom [1]
fanfic [36]
- yuletide [36]
fantasy of manners [6]
finance [3]
food [46]
football [36]
for sale [3]
futuresibling [6]
games [7]
- 80 days [3]
- fallen london [7]
gender [19]
genre [8]
giveaways [15]
gratitude [8]
harassment [1]
health and beauty [30]
help me internets [14]
history [3]
hobbit birthday presents [1]
house [37]
icons [20]
identity [3]
iditarod [1]
international blog against racism week [15]
law [30]
links [202]
livejournal [16]
livelongnmarry [5]
manga [23]
manga analysis [9]
manga
- fullmetal alchemist [28]
- saiyuki [18]
masks [1]
memes [31]
movies [123]
- harry potter [3]
- lord of the rings [6]
- mcu [60]
- serenity [7]
- star wars [5]
- the hobbit [3]
- trailers [40]
museums [22]
music [59]
- playlist exchange [4]
nanoblocks [1]
nasty bugs etc. [11]
navel-gazing [4]
organization for transformative works [1]
parenting [10]
pictures [53]
podcasts [4]
- friends at the table [10]
- welcome to night vale [11]
politics [15]
polls [30]
power outages [7]
pregnancy [37]
public domain boobs [4]
race [62]
randomosity [9]
rants [2]
recommendations [46]
religion [2]
science [3]
sexuality [9]
sff [78]
- hugos [22]
- locus notes [2]
silliness [1]
silly [19]
social media [1]
sports [2]
steelykid [54]
- developmental updates [16]
stitching [38]
teaching company courses [3]
tech [64]
the pip [19]
theater [28]
- hamilton [8]
toys [1]
trips [58]
- japan 2007 [26]
- london 2014 [8]
- rome 2016 [6]
tumblr [1]
tv [17]
- adventure time [1]
- avatar [6]
- burn notice [1]
- elementary [4]
- face off [4]
- farscape [5]
- firefly [20]
- heroes [3]
- homicide [5]
- jonathan strange [1]
- jonathan strange & mr norrell [10]
- leverage [5]
- lost [24]
- sherlock (bbc) [2]
- stargate atlantis [1]
- steven universe [73]
- the good place [21]
- the untamed [4]
- the wire [2]
- wheel of time [3]
- white collar [4]
video games [1]
videos [5]
vids [6]
website [14]
writing [11]

Page Summary

kate_nepveu - (no subject)

Style Credit

Style: Neutral Good for Practicality by timeasmymeasure

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags

incidents and accidents, hints and allegations

Harry Potter & the Chamber of Secrets (spoilers)